in

Why the BMW N47 Engine is THE MOST Unreliable BMW Engine?

BMW N47 Engine Timing Chain Failure

Introduction

The BMW N47 is a four-cylinder inline diesel engine, it’s the successor to the BMW M47 engine. It ranges from 1.6 to 2.0-liters in displacement and outputs 94 to 204hp as per the configuration. It, being a modern engine, complies with the stricter emission standards using EGR and DPF technology, which leads to some of the problems this engine faces. All the major and minor problems that you should expect when driving this engine are discussed below.

This engine has been fitted in the BMW 1 series, 5 series, and 3 series 4-cylinder diesel variants.

The Problems

Timing Chain Premature Failure

BMW N47 Timing Chain
BMW N47 Engine Timing Chain

The timing chain inside the BMW N47 engine suffers from excessive wear and premature breakdowns. It can collapse while the engine is running, which causes serious damage to the engine. It mostly requires a complete engine replacement if the damage is severe or requires some major repairs. A failing timing chain can be diagnosed with a rattling noise from the rear side of the engine. The timing chain seats between the engine and the transmission at the rear end of the engine, thus requiring either the engine to be removed or the transmission to be detached to replace the timing chain.

EGR Sensor Malfunction

The EGR system was designed to help the car meet stricter emissions standards. It recirculates a part of the exhaust gases back into the intake to reduce the amount of nitrogen oxide. But this system starts malfunctioning when the sensor gets covered in soot. It then makes more and more exhaust air recirculate into the intake. The hot exhaust gases cause the plastic intake manifold to melt and leak out in some scenarios. This opened valve also results in a reduction in boost pressure.

A widely opened EGR valve can result in soot build up on the Fuel injectors, intake manifold and the glow plugs. It results in reduced airflow due to the restrictions and prevents the car from starting easily in winters.

PDF Not Working in Short Runs

DPF filters out soot or diesel particulate matter from the exhaust gases. It functionally operates under high temperatures. On frequent shorter journeys, this DPF does not get hot enough to remove the soot and exhaust gases manage to get out unfiltered. This results in soot build up on your turbo, DPF sensor, EGR sensor and even on your engines glow plugs.

Power Steering Pump Failure

The power steering pump is also not much reliable on these engines. A failing power steering pump can be identified from oil spillage around the cap of steering oil reservoir.

Crank Case Breather Hose Oil Leakage Under High Temperature

The rubber crank case breather hose leaks out typically under high temperature. This is indicated by oil leakage from the hose end. This problem was however resolved by BMW by replacing it with a stiffer plastic hose.

Conclusion

So, if you are among the owners of a car equipped with the BMW N47 engine, look out for the timing chain making any rattling noise, it is suitable to replace it around 60-100k miles. Do clean your car’s EGR sensor on timely oil changes to avoid unnecessary soot build in your intake and engine components. If you get a good deal on selling it, go for it as it is better to just avoid this engine, then to own and babysit it.

What do you think?

215 points
Upvote Downvote
5 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

21 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Simon H
Simon H
2 years ago

Compared to the N43 Petrol engine the N47 is a paragon of reliability

Jack D
Jack D
2 years ago
Reply to  Liviu Marcus

You obviously don’t have a clue about this engine. How can you say it’s the most unreliable, did you heard about N57 ? the 6 pot inline one ? Is even more unreliable from this perspective. I have a 320d rwd 2010 with the N47 engine from new and never missed a beat. I did all the preventative maintenance, oil and filters and at about 175k miles I replaced the timing chain kit along with crankshaft pulley, tensioner belt, water pump, etc My mechanic told me the tensioner and guides on the old timing chain would have lasted at least 100k miles. Apart from that once I had to change the glow plug relay and the glow plugs with it. The car is 190k miles now and it still runs strong, remapped from 70k on the clock to 210 hp. The secret here is to change the oil frequently, I do it every 3000 – 4500 miles.
I would advise that you do not post such articles, confusing people, maybe someone wants to buy a car with this engine and stumbles upon your post.

John
John
2 years ago
Reply to  Liviu Marcus

This whole article is a shit show. The premise for “the most unreliable BMW engine [ever]” is garbage. It sounds like this article was written by a fifth-grader who has no idea what the assignment is about.

Bess
Bess
1 year ago
Reply to  Jack D

You are a disaster with your car. The BMW’s N47 is a crap engine, you’re just lucky 1 in a million. I had a brand new 08 M-Sport BMW 520d, engine shit itself 100k, changing oil and service every 3000k. Cost me a fortune only was 2 years old, first went chain then Conrod. They are bags of shit. It’s a scrap car, never ever go near BMW.

Mervyn
Mervyn
2 years ago

I purchased a 120d m sport 2008 with 120 miles on her original timing chain, I replaced it and the clutch whilst I had the engine out, it is one of the nicest driving cars I’ve owned and that is numerous, change the oil and filter and she will last for ever.i read about all the crap engines on various forums written by boys who have their MECHANIC fix their cars as they would know hot to fill the washer bottle, write about how unreliable a engine check out ebay and gumtree some of these engines are hitting 200k.

Misko
Misko
2 years ago

This is my 2nd N47 engine. With the first 118d, I had around 40t km without any problems, just regular oil change up to 12t km. The guy who I sold it to, he still didn’t change the chain. Now I am driving 320D ’09. After three months from buying, I did the BIG service ( chains and everything ), daily driving and I am having with it currently 80tkm.
You Sir, are running GOSSIP magazine !

Mike Alexander
Mike Alexander
2 years ago

I have had my engine replaced by BMW, also even though not required, the flywheel and clutch, but since 1000 miles appeared fuel injectors going [ 3rd set] clutch shake, emissions failure, air-con problems… heating not working correctly and lack of power… Sytner estimate £6,600 to sort out… I had to pay 50% of the labor, BMW and Sytner say the engine cost £11,300 and the labor £2,300… plus FW and Clutch £1,500… Why have these items gone wrong since the engine was replaced, and it was a short block engine replacement… Advice, please…

James
James
1 year ago
Reply to  Liviu Marcus

I have only just seen this discussion and tbh l do not know who got there information from where. There was a recall back around 2010 on faulty chains BMW set out to rectify this issue. At that time l worked for the BMW plant UK.
I have owned a 225d 2014 M sport for 8yrs been a great drive excellent fuelling and serviced by BMW as required. Currently done 100,000 miles and still going strong. This not a one off car l know quite a few people who would disagree with you.
And to tbh it certainly is not the worst engine in the BMW range any many others would agree

Mike
Mike
1 year ago

What a ridiculous post. You make it sound like this Engine fails all the time. Are you trying to get a Job with the Daily Mail ? As with this kind of scaremongering you are ideal fit for that type of paper!

MARK
MARK
1 year ago
Reply to  Liviu Marcus

The article is right. How did i get hear?
How many sufferers of these vehicles actually take to the various websites and forums and owners clubs to air the their experiances? They either pay up to the dealers or indys and get their cars fixed and go on about their normal lives…

This engine has been picked up by TV and there have been legal proceedings against BMW Ireland.

These engines are used in the BMW range including the Mini and the 1.6 is used in the Toyota Avensis. I know about the latter i have a 2017 Avensis full service history with only 47000 with a broken (wait for it) Timing Chain!

Its even had the Turbo replaced at 28000 miles Really i hear you ask? Yes
Full Toyota Service History!!
What a great engine (in a sarchastic manner)

MARK
MARK
1 year ago
Reply to  Mike

Mike Do your own homework

The article is right. How did i get here?

How many sufferers of these vehicles actually take to the various websites and forums and owners clubs to air the their experiances? They either pay up to the dealers or indys and get their cars fixed and go on about their normal lives…

This engine has been picked up by TV and there have been legal proceedings against BMW Ireland.

These engines are used in the BMW range including the Mini and the 1.6 is used in the Toyota Avensis. I know about the latter i have a 2017 Avensis full service history with only 47000 with a broken (wait for it) Timing Chain!

Its even had the Turbo replaced at 28000 miles Really i hear you ask? Yes
Full Toyota Service History!!
What a great engine (in a sarchastic manner)

Written by Liviu Marcus

Liviu is the founder and chief editor of Automotivesblog. He is passionate about cars, computers, and technology, and these things are part of his everyday life. He likes to do research on everything that exists in the automotive industry in order to share with you the most important information in this field. Many nights were lost for this, but Liviu has no regrets as long as everything he does is a passion—the passion for cars and everything related to them.

Best Motorcycle Helmet

Is ECE Better than DOT Approval?

I Refueled the Car with Diesel Instead of Gasoline

WHAT TO DO If I Refueled the Car with Diesel Instead of Gasoline? and Vice Versa?